We have somehow succeeded in potty training Tommy. Once a mom succeeds at this feat it's funny how fast other moms want to know how you did it. I was definitely one of those moms a few months ago. I don't profess to be an expert, but I do know how to potty train my own child, so I guess that's worth something. Over the past several months I have read everything I could about potty training. I gleaned ideas from everyone that has ever succeeded at potty training a child. Somehow I put it all together and came up with something that worked for Tommy. I write this in an effort to help other desperate moms. Maybe something we did will help you.
I thought I'd start this post off with a few humorous potty training tips that I found especially unhelpful. Keep in mind that my son just turned two in June and that he is quite, um, let's say independent:
- Give your son one M&M when he goes pee and two when he goes poop in the potty. So, we tried this on our first attempt back in March and it totally blew up in our faces. I didn't know this before March, but apparently there are kids out there that will not be bought or bribed, and I happen to be the mother of one of those kids. When we try to bribe him he defiantly does the opposite of what we want him to. That's a good trait in general, but a little disappointing when it came to potty training:)
- Put Cheerios in the toilet and let him aim at them. My son is more likely to reach into the toilet to eat the Cheerio than he is to aim at it with his pee. He is also likely to think it's fun to throw things into the toilet, and we are trying to avoid teaching him that at all costs. Maybe older boys find that motivating. I don't know, and I'm not going to try it.
- Wait until your child is ready to potty train. Okay, seriously, what does that even mean? How can a toddler make an intellectual decision about when they think they are ready to learn to use the toilet? I know people will disagree with me on this, and that's fine. I'm just saying, don't expect your toddler to come to you and say, "I'm ready to use the potty now," unless you want to wait years longer than we did for him to learn to use the potty.
- Let your child run around the house naked. When he pees on the floor he'll be upset and then you can simply teach him where the pee pee goes. Don't judge me, but we actually tried this for a couple of hours and you know what happened? He peed on stuff and I cleaned it up and it didn't teach him a thing about using the potty. I hear this works well for some people, but we didn't find it to be especially helpful.
Let's rewind a few months. I started getting a little panicked when Tommy started wearing size 6 diapers when he was about 16 months old. Size 6 is the largest they sell in stores. You can special order size 7, but I really wanted to avoid the cost of doing that. Tommy had shown a little bit of interest in the potty at about that time. I got a potty seat that goes over the big potty and he liked to sit on it and pretend to wipe his bum with toilet paper. He liked watching us go potty, but that was as far as his interest went. In January I found out that a friend of mine in the ward had just succeeded at potty training her 23-month-old son so I pestered her about how she did it. She followed the Three Day Potty Training program by Lora Jensen so I thought we would give it a try. The basic idea is that you put your kid in underpants and give them tons to drink. You stay right by their side the entire day and when they start to wet, you scoop them up and run them to the potty. You never ask them if they need to go. You only take them to the potty when either they have an accident or they tell you they need to go. It worked for her so I gave it a try.
This was back in March. Tommy was just barely 21-months-old. We spent a very long morning running to the potty and cleaning up accidents, but after about six hours he actually got it! I was amazed and so proud of him. He was accident free for the rest of the first day and all of the second day. I couldn't believe it! But, that's about when it started to fall apart. I made several mistakes and take full responsibility, but I learned a lot from it. The major mistake I made was that I hovered too much over Tommy and pushed him too much that he started to push back. I was constantly at full alert, so afraid that he would have an accident, constantly putting him on the potty when I thought he needed to go even though he didn't tell me that he did. It turned into a power struggle, which is the worst thing that can happen during potty training. I was stressed out and so was he. He started having accidents any time I turned my back. I wasn't getting anything around the house done because I had to watch him all the time. He stopped telling me he needed to go, so I started forcing him onto the potty more and more. It was bad. We stuck with it for over a week, but it finally reached a point where I couldn't do it anymore. I broke down one night and uttered the words that moms only say when they really reach the breaking point: "I don't want to be a mom anymore!" It was awful. I was worried I was ruining Tommy. I was worried about giving up and going back to diapers because I didn't want to teach him that it was okay to quit something because it is hard. I felt like a failure. We put him back in diapers and forgot about potty training for a couple of months. I vowed never to try again. I had no idea that potty training was going to be so emotional.
I did learn a thing or two from our first try, though. The most important thing I learned is that different kids are motivated by different incentives. Tommy doesn't care what other kids are doing. He doesn't care what I want him to do. He doesn't care about the rewards. He could care less about a sticker chart. I learned all of this through our first attempt. Some kids respond really well to those types of things, but not Tommy.
I learned that the only thing that motivates Tommy is control. He thrives on doing things by himself. He thrives on doing the things grown ups do. He loves to choose his own clothes. He loves to help me do chores around the house. He loves to help me shop. He just loves to be big, so that's what I had to use to motivate him to use the potty. For weeks before we tried again I told him how babies wear diapers, but big boys wear underpants. We talked about how big boys go potty in the toilet. During the process of potty training I often had to use things like, "When you go potty you can zip up your own pants," or, "You can wash your hands by yourself if we go potty," or, "You can flush the toilet by yourself when you go potty in it." Doing things by himself was the incentive I used the most (although we definitely rewarded him with treats and lots of praise to make the experience more enjoyable). If you have an independent (or stubborn) kid on your hands, this might work for you, too.
Well, with the encouragement of seeing some more friends potty train their children I decided to give it another try. I read "How to Potty Train Your Child in Just One Day," by Teri Crane, which is a much softer approach to potty training. The basic idea of this program is that you throw your child a potty party. You decorate the house according to a theme of your choice, you serve treats, you open presents. In the morning you have your child potty train a doll or stuffed animal and then in the afternoon you potty train the child. It sounded nice, but I didn't think Tommy would really get the whole party thing. Older kids with big imaginations would probably love something like that, but Tommy just turned two at the beginning of June, so he wasn't quite there yet. Plus, you are only supposed to watch potty training videos and read potty training books and talk only about potty training the whole day. I thought that would be too intense for Tommy. But, we took some ideas from that book, combined them with ideas from our first attempt, and added on a few more ideas I got from reading friend's blogs.
Like I said above, we started talking about how big boys wear underpants several weeks in advance. Then one Sunday morning we put his big stuffed monkey in underpants and had Tommy teach the monkey how to go potty. It surprised me how much he enjoyed doing that. I think it's because he had all the control in the role of teacher. After teaching monkey a few times Tommy wanted to wear big boy underpants. He stayed in them the first time for about two hours without an accident, so that was good. I reminded him every few minutes to keep his underpants dry and I praised him every time he said his underpants were still dry. We pretended the monkey had an accident and had Tommy teach the monkey again how to go potty on the toilet. We continued to do this for a couple of weeks. Tommy loved teaching the monkey how to go potty and sometimes he even wore underpants himself. Once he had an accident he wanted a diaper again and I always gave it to him. It wasn't easy. He got upset every time he had an accident. I felt like I was setting him up to fail every time he wanted to wear underpants because I knew he would have an accident and then get upset about it. But, I stuck with it for about a week and gave him underpants when he wanted them, reminded him to keep them dry, and told him every few minutes, "Tell Mommy when you need to go potty." I never asked him if he needed to go. I don't know how other kids are, but if you ask Tommy if he needs to go potty he will always say no. It's like asking him if he's tired. He'll never admit it. So I put the ball in his court and let him tell me when he needed to go.
After about a week of doing this and wondering if it was doing any good, Tommy gave us some encouragement. We were at Stake Conference and he had a diaper on. It was like 11:00 in the morning and he looked at me and said, "Need potty." You better believe I jumped up and took him to the potty! It turns out he had kept his diaper dry all morning and he actually went on the potty when I took him. It made my week.
After that happened I realized that he just needed a little push to really be potty trained. I needed a little push, too. So we removed our safety net: diapers. A few days later (this was just a few days after his second birthday) I told him that we were out of diapers and that he was a big boy and needed to wear big boy underpants. We combined everything we had been doing and worked on potty training most of the morning. We took the monkey potty, I reminded him to keep his underpants dry, I told him to tell me when he needed to go potty. He was accident free in the morning, but only because he held it until about noon and then basically exploded when I set him on the potty without him asking me to go. He wore pull ups for his nap and then had an accident in the evening. After the accident he asked for a diaper and I told him he couldn't have one because we didn't have anymore. It was basically the same thing the next day. He asked for his "sleep pants" (pull ups) a few times, but I told him that those were only for sleeping and that he needed to wear his big boy underpants. He was pretty good to comply.
So on the third day I decided to change my strategy a little bit. He hadn't told me that he needed to go once and I wondered if this was sinking in at all. He was a master at holding it, but I knew that wouldn't get us too far. I knew he could tell me because he had done it during Stake Conference a few days previous. My goal was to get him to tell me when he needed to go so that I could relax. So I decided to have a really intense potty day with him, and it worked beautifully.
I gave him a ton to drink so that we would have plenty of opportunities to practice going potty. I also set a timer to go off every 10-20 minutes throughout the day. Every time it buzzed it was potty time and we ran and sat on the potty. Sometimes we skipped or walked on our tip toes to the bathroom to make it more fun. We read lots of books on the potty that day (something I vowed never to do) to make it more enjoyable to sit there. The timer wasn't meant to be permanent, it was just meant to give him lots of practice without me being the one to constantly tell him to go. We didn't go anywhere, not even outside. I had lots of inside activities to do and we really just focused on potty training. Every time I needed to go potty that day I made a big deal about it and imitated what I wanted him to do: grabbed my crotch, danced around, said I needed to go potty, asked Tommy if he would help me. Maybe that sounds ridiculous or gross to some people, but the best way Tommy learns is by watching what we do. It was a really long day, but it worked better than I had even hoped. All morning, every 10-20 minutes we sat on the potty and nothing happened. Not one drop. Then finally around 11:30 we were coloring and Tommy jumped up, grabbed his crotch, said "Potty!" and ran for the bathroom. I couldn't believe my eyes and ears! I was so proud of him I gave him a bowl of ice cream afterward.
The next day we continued with the timer, but it quickly turned into a power struggle. He started running away from me every time the buzzer went off and refusing to go potty. I knew this would happen, so we stopped the timer idea. I told him very clearly that I wouldn't make him sit on the potty anymore as long as he told me when he needed to go. It was hard because I was still so afraid of him having an accident! But, I decided that I needed to let go and embrace accidents as a part of the learning process. Either he was going to tell me he needed to go or he was going to have an accident. And you know what? A couple of hours later he was still accident free and he actually told me when he needed to go. He has been completely accident free since the second day we started this (it's been over a week now) and he is really good at letting me know when he needs to go, even when we are at the park or otherwise away from home.
I don't want anyone to think that this has been easy, because it hasn't. He grasped onto potty training within a few days this time, but I think a lot of has to do with the prior training we did in March, plus all the weeks of preparation that led up to him taking the plunge last week. I also don't want anyone to think that I am bragging that my just-barely-two-year-old can use the potty. I'm not. It's his accomplishment and I am very proud of him for it, but the only reason I am writing this post is because several people have asked for it. I hope it helps someone out there as much as other friends have helped me. Also, I don't want anyone to think Tommy is smarter than other kids. I know he is the smartest kids in the world, but that's just because I'm his mom:) I really think any toddler can learn how to use the potty as early as their parents are willing and able to teach them in a way that works for that child. I'm sure Tommy could have been potty trained back in March, but I made several mistakes that inhibited the learning process.
Many people have asked me if I will potty train my other kids early like I did for Tommy. My answer is unequivocally "YES". Potty training is not easy, whenever you do it. It's emotional and it's messy and it's a lot of work. I say do it early and get it over with. From my informal observation it often takes the oldest child a couple of serious tries to get potty trained. I think however old the child is, he's going to remember what he learned the first time. In addition, the parents learn a lot the first time around and it makes the second attempt much smoother. That's just what I have seen with my friends and family members (and myself). So don't get discouraged if the first time doesn't stick. Chance are the second time will be much easier.
I hope this helps someone! If you ever have questions about what we did or if you just want to vent about the woes of potty training your own child, post a comment, send me an email, or give me a call. I know how it is:)



























